Your neighbor just had their house re-sided, and you can’t help but notice how incredible those natural wood shingles look. That rich texture, the warm tones, the way light hits each individual shake differently throughout the day.
You’re considering cedar shake siding for your home, but you’ve also heard stories about the upkeep and expenses that make you hesitate. Let’s talk through everything you need to know about cedar shake siding so you can figure out if it’s the right fit for your home.
What Makes Cedar Shake Siding Different?
Cedar shake siding brings something special to a home’s exterior that other materials simply can’t replicate. These aren’t your typical flat panels. Real wood shakes have irregular surfaces, natural grain patterns, and a texture that creates depth and character on any structure.
Western red cedar is the most popular choice for this type of siding, and there’s good reason for that. This wood naturally resists moisture and insects better than most other species. It’s also lighter than you’d expect, which means your wall doesn’t need extra reinforcement like it might with heavier materials.
Cedar Versus Other Siding Materials
How does cedar shake siding compare to what else is out there? Each material has its place, and the right choice for your neighbor might not fit your situation.
| Feature | Cedar Shake Siding | Vinyl Siding | Fiber Cement |
| Natural Appearance | Authentic wood grain | Synthetic | Manufactured texture |
| Lifespan | 30-40 years | 20-30 years | 50+ years |
| Maintenance Level | High | Low | Medium |
| Insulation Value | Excellent | Fair | Good |
| Cost per Sq. Ft. | $6-$15 | $3-$7 | $5-$10 |
Vinyl Siding
Vinyl wins on low maintenance and initial cost. It’s easy to clean, never needs painting, and holds up well to the elements. But it looks synthetic because it is. You won’t get the depth and character that real wood creates. It can also crack in extreme cold or warp in intense heat.
Fiber Cement
This option sits somewhere in the middle. Fiber cement can mimic the look of wood reasonably well, and it’s far more durable than cedar. Pests won’t touch it, and rot isn’t a concern. However, it’s heavy, harder to install, and still doesn’t match the authentic appearance of natural wood shingles.
Metal Siding
Metal offers excellent durability and virtually no maintenance. It protects against fire and extreme weather better than cedar. The tradeoff? It looks industrial unless you invest in premium finishes, and it doesn’t provide the same insulation benefits.
Other Wood Options
You could go with different wood species, but cedar remains the top choice for exterior applications. Pine and spruce cost less but need more aggressive treatment to prevent rot. They simply don’t have cedar’s natural resistance to moisture and insects.
Why Cedar Shake Siding Is The Right Choice
There’s something undeniably appealing about natural wood on your exterior. When you choose cedar shakes, you’re getting a one-of-a-kind look. No two pieces are identical, so your home won’t have the cookie-cutter feel you see with manufactured options.
The insulation properties alone make cedar worth considering. Wood naturally regulates temperature better than most siding materials on the market today. According to the Department of Energy, proper siding contributes significantly to a home’s overall energy efficiency. Your heating and cooling costs could drop noticeably, especially if you’re replacing older, less efficient siding.
Cedar shingles also offer impressive design versatility. You can leave them untreated for that weathered, rustic look. Or go with stained finishes in virtually any color you want. Some homeowners prefer painted cedar for a smooth, refined appearance that retains the wood’s natural texture beneath.
The longevity factor matters too. Quality cedar shake shingles can protect your home for 30 to 40 years when properly maintained. That’s a solid investment compared to cheaper alternatives that need replacement much sooner.
The Downsides of Cedar Shake Siding
Let’s be honest about the downsides of cedar shake siding. This material requires attention. Unlike vinyl or fiber cement, which you can basically install and forget about, cedar needs regular care to extend its life and maintain its beauty.
Moisture is cedar’s biggest enemy. Even though western red cedar resists rot better than other woods, it’s not foolproof. Water that gets trapped behind the shingles or sits in poorly ventilated areas will eventually cause damage. You’ll need to inspect your siding regularly, especially after heavy storms.
Here’s what the maintenance schedule can look like:
- Clean your cedar with a garden hose and mild detergent every year
- Reapply protective finishes every 3-5 years, depending on exposure
- Replace damaged or warped shakes as soon as you spot them
- Check for signs of insects or termites seasonally
Cost is another consideration that stops many homeowners. Professional siding installation for cedar costs significantly more than for other materials. You’re paying for the wood itself and for the expertise needed to install it correctly. Proper installation is necessary to prevent moisture problems down the line.
Cedar left untreated will turn gray over time. Some people love that silvered, weathered look. Others hate it. If you want to keep the original rich color, you’ll need to apply and maintain a quality stain or sealer. That’s extra time and money you need to factor in.
Cedar Siding Costs: Breaking Down the Numbers
Installation costs depend on several factors beyond just the material itself. Your geographical location plays a huge role. Labor rates vary widely, and so does the availability of high-quality western red cedar across regions.
Expect to pay between $8,000 and $25,000 for an average-sized home. That’s a broad range because there are multiple layers to pricing:
- The grade of cedar you choose (clear grade costs more but looks better)
- The complexity of your home’s structure
- Whether you’re removing old siding first
- The number of corners, windows, and architectural details
- Your local labor market rates
Don’t forget ongoing costs either. You’ll spend several hundred dollars every few years on stain or sealant. Add cleaning supplies and potential repairs to that line item. If you hire professionals to handle maintenance, those costs add up quickly.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cedar Shake Siding
How long does cedar shake siding really last?
With proper maintenance, you’re looking at 30 to 40 years, sometimes longer. The keyword there is “proper.” If you neglect cleaning and refinishing, you might only get 15 to 20 years before replacement becomes necessary.
Can I install cedar shakes myself, or should I hire professionals?
Installing cedar shakes requires specific techniques to ensure proper overlap, ventilation, and water drainage. Most manufacturers recommend professional installation to maintain warranty coverage. One mistake can lead to expensive moisture damage later.
What’s the difference between cedar shakes and cedar shingles?
Cedar shakes are split rather than sawn, giving them a rougher, more rustic texture. Cedar shingles are sawn smooth on both sides, creating a more refined appearance. Both are popular choices. It just depends on the style you want.
Do I need to treat cedar shake siding right away?
Yes, treating your cedar soon after installation helps protect it from day one. Some people prefer letting it weather naturally first. However, you’ll get better long-term protection by applying a quality stain or sealant within a few months of installation.
Will cedar siding increase my home’s value?
Natural wood siding, especially western red cedar, typically adds value because buyers appreciate the premium look and quality. Just make sure it’s well-maintained. Damaged or neglected cedar can actually hurt your resale value.
Making Your Decision
Cedar shake siding delivers something special that manufactured materials can’t touch. But here’s the thing: all the maintenance schedules, cost considerations, and material comparisons can feel overwhelming. You’re trying to protect one of your biggest investments while making it look amazing.
You don’t have to figure this out alone. Ready to explore whether cedar shake siding is the right choice for your home? Call us at (402) 651-1493 or message us here to schedule a free siding installation consultation. We’ll walk through your options together and help you make a decision you’ll feel good about for decades to come.